What is Bare Ownership?

CATEGORY: Real Estate Guide

What is bare ownership? Bare ownership is one of the most particular forms of real estate investment on the Italian scene and offers interesting opportunities for both sellers and buyers. This legal instrument makes it possible to separate the ownership of a property from the right to inhabit it, creating win-win scenarios for both parties involved in the transaction.

Understanding the mechanics of bare ownership is essential for those who want to explore innovative alternatives in the real estate market. For those who want to sell, bare ownership allows you to receive liquidity immediately while maintaining the right to live in the property. For those who buy, it represents a long-term investment opportunity with a low initial cost.

In this article, we will examine in detail all the aspects related to bare ownership: what the law provides, what are the tax implications, the benefits and risks, as well as the practical methods of buying and selling. The goal is to provide a comprehensive guide to evaluate this type of investment in the real estate sector in an informed way.

Bare Ownership: what is it?

Bare ownership is a type of real estate contract in which ownership of a property is separated from the right of usufruct. The buyer (bare owner) gains ownership of the property, but cannot use it until the usufruct expires, which usually lasts for the lifetime of the seller (usufructuary).

The rights and obligations of the bare owner

The bare owner retains formal ownership of the property and can sell, donate or mortgage it. When the usufruct ceases, he automatically obtains full ownership. During the period of usufruct, he may not use, rent or derive income from the property, unless otherwise agreed with the usufructuary for joint management of the property. Extraordinary expenses remain at his expense.

The rights and obligations of the usufructuary

The usufructuary has the right to use the property, inhabit it, rent it and collect the relevant rents. However, the leases entered into by the usufructuary cease with the end of the usufruct, except for exceptions provided for by law (e.g. for agricultural leases). The usufructuary can carry out acts of ordinary administration and must bear the costs of ordinary maintenance. He is also obliged to return the property at the end of the usufruct in the state in which he received it, except for normal deterioration resulting from use. Acts of extraordinary administration (such as selling or mortgaging the property) remain the responsibility of the bare owner.

A property divided into two

This separation creates a particular situation in which two subjects have complementary rights over the same property: the bare owner holds the formal ownership, while the usufructuary enjoys the right of use and economic fruits.

Bare ownership: The regulatory framework in Italy

The discipline of bare ownership derives indirectly from the rules governing usufruct, as ownership can be divided between bare owner and usufructuary. The regulation is found in the Civil Code in articles 978 to 1020.

Article 981 defines usufruct as “the right to enjoy the property of others with the obligation to respect its economic destination”.
According to Article 979, usufruct has a limited duration: if granted to a natural person, it ends with the life of the usufructuary, while, if attributed to a legal person, it cannot exceed the maximum limit of thirty years.

The legislation defines in detail the rights and duties of the parties, the procedures for the establishment and the reasons for the termination. Of particular importance is Article 1001, which regulates the obligations of the usufructuary with regard to the maintenance and conservation of the property: he is required to carry out ordinary repairs and return the property in the condition in which it was delivered to him, except for deterioration due to normal use. Extraordinary expenses, on the other hand, are the responsibility of the owner.

The usufruct is extinguished for various reasons: expiry of the term, death of the usufructuary, renunciation, consolidation (when bare ownership and usufruct are united in the same person), twenty-year prescription for non-use, loss of the thing subject to usufruct, abuse by the usufructuary and other hypotheses provided for by the Code.

The advantages of bare ownership

For buyers, the main attraction is the low purchase price. This opportunity allows them to invest in properties that would otherwise be out of their financial reach, creating the conditions for an attractive return in the long term.

Long-term investment in bare ownership can prove to be very profitable. Once the usufruct has ceased, the buyer becomes the full owner of a property paid significantly less than its market value. Meanwhile, the value of the property can appreciate, amplifying the return on the initial investment.

This form of investment also offers natural protection against real estate inflation. While property prices tend to rise over time, the initial cost incurred remains fixed, generating a real gain in purchasing power.

For investors with long time horizons and limited financial resources, bare ownership is an attractive alternative to other traditional forms of real estate investment.

Advantages for the seller

For those who sell bare ownership, the main advantages are:

  • Immediate liquidity: The seller gets a sum of money right away, but retains the right of residence (usufruct) on the property until the end of their life or for the agreed period. This solution is particularly interesting for older people who want to pay for medical expenses, help family members or simply improve their lifestyle without having to leave their home.
  • Continuity in the home: the seller can continue to live in the property while maintaining his habits and emotional bond with the house, without drastic changes in everyday life.
  • Tax advantages: in many cases, the sale of the bare ownership of the main residence does not generate taxable capital gains if held for at least five years and the seller is not required to pay the registration tax, which is the responsibility of the buyer.
  • Succession planning: the sale in bare ownership often allows for more efficient management of assets and succession, reducing the inheritance subject to taxation and simplifying any divisions between heirs.

Benefits for the buyer of bare ownership

From the buyer’s point of view, this mode offers the following benefits:

  • Purchase at a subsidized price: the price of bare ownership is lower than the full market value of the property, often with a significant discount that depends on the age of the usufructuary and actuarial tables.
  • Long-term investment: buying bare ownership is a wealth strategy that allows you to plan the full availability of the property over time, revaluing it without further future disbursements at the end of the usufruct.
  • Absence of management problems: during the period of usufruct, ordinary expenses and maintenance generally remain the responsibility of the usufructuary, freeing the buyer from many practical tasks until the reacquisition of full ownership.
  • Possibility of future income: at the expiration of the usufruct, the buyer obtains full ownership of the property, being able to dispose of it as he sees fit (sale, lease, personal use).

Risks and considerations for sellers in bare ownership

The main disadvantage of selling bare ownership is the reduced market value. The sale price is usually 30-50% lower than the market value of the property, depending on the age of the usufructuary and other specific factors.

The calculation of the discount is based on actuarial tables that consider the life expectancy of the usufructuary. The younger the person, the greater the discount applied to the value of the property. Other factors influence the valuation: location of the property, state of conservation, attractiveness on the market, and general conditions of the local real estate market.

Relational dynamics with the buyer can generate complications. It is essential to establish clear rules from the beginning regarding maintenance, changes to the property, and the responsibilities of the parties. A lack of contractual clarity can lead to disputes that compromise the serenity of both parties.

The seller must also consider that, once the sale has been completed, he will no longer be able to freely dispose of the property. Any future sales needs or substantial changes will require the consent of the bare owner.

Risks and considerations for buyers in bare ownership

Delay in actual possession is the main risk for those who buy bare ownership. The uncertainty about the actual availability of the property makes this investment unsuitable for those who need short-term liquidity.

The life expectancy of the usufructuary is a fundamental but unpredictable variable. Actuarial tables provide statistical estimates, but the actual duration of the usufruct can deviate significantly from the forecasts, affecting the return on investment.

Maintenance responsibilities can generate unexpected costs and disputes. Although routine maintenance is the responsibility of the usufructuary, extraordinary maintenance is generally the responsibility of the bare owner. The distinction between the two types of maintenance is not always clear and can cause conflicts.

Buyers must also consider that the property may deteriorate during the usufruct period, reducing the final value of the investment. It is therefore essential to accurately assess the condition of the property and the seriousness of the usufructuary before proceeding with the purchase.

How to evaluate bare ownership

The assessment of bare ownership requires specific methodologies that take into account the separation between full ownership and usufruct. In Italy, the most widely used method is based on the coefficients established by the Ministry of Finance with the Ministerial Decree of 26 April 2001 (periodically updated on the basis of the legal interest rate), which correlate the age of the usufructuary with the value of the usufruct.

The calculation takes place in three phases:

  1. determination of the market value of the property;
  2. calculation of the value of the usufruct based on the age of the usufructuary and ministerial coefficients;
  3. These factors do not affect the legal calculation, but can weigh on the negotiation between seller and buyer.

In addition to the method based on the tables established by law, other factors may affect the practice of the market, such as the trend of the local real estate market, the maintenance conditions of the property and the existence of any urban planning constraints.

To obtain a correct valuation and protect both parties, it is advisable to contact qualified professionals (notaries, accountants, appraisers or real estate consultants), so as to avoid calculation errors and consequent economic losses.

Reference table updated to 2025 (legal rate 2.5%)

Reference table updated to 2025 (legal rate 2.5%)
Age of the usufructuary Usufruct value (% of the full property value) Bare property value (%)
0 – 20 years95%5%
21 – 30 years90%10%
31 – 40 years 85%15%
41 – 45 years 80%20%
46 – 50 years 75%25%
51 – 53 years 70%30%
54 – 56 years65%35%
57 – 60 years60%40%
61 – 63 years 55%45%
64 – 66 years 50%50%
67 – 69 years 45%55%
70 – 72 years40%60%
73 – 75 years 35%65%
76 – 78 years30%70%
79 – 82 years25%75%
83 – 86 years20%80%
87 – 92 years10%90%
Over 92 years 5%95%

The process of buying and selling in bare ownership

The sale of bare ownership requires a professional and careful approach.

The search for specialized real estate advice is the first fundamental step. Not all operators in the sector have specific experience with this type of transaction, which presents particular complexities compared to traditional sales.

Specialized legal advice is essential for both parties. A lawyer experienced in real estate law can guide the negotiation, verify the documentation, and prepare contracts that adequately protect the interests of sellers and buyers.

The due diligence must be particularly thorough. In addition to the standard checks (title deed, urban planning compliance, absence of mortgages), it is necessary to investigate the specific aspects of the usufruct: duration, any limitations, obligations of the parties.

During the negotiation, it is essential to clearly define all aspects of future coexistence: maintenance responsibilities, the possibility of changes to the property, management of utilities, and procedures for resolving any conflicts.

The role of the notary is central in the finalization of the transaction. The notary verifies the legitimacy of the transaction, ascertains the will of the parties, and prepares the public deed that formalizes the transfer of the bare ownership.

” Bare ownership offers several benefits: a lower initial investment, the possibility of significant long-term gains, and the absence of management burdens during the usufruct period. However, it carries risks due to the unpredictability of completion times and the absence of immediate gains.”

Tax implications in bare ownership

The tax treatment of bare ownership includes some special characteristics that require an in-depth analysis:

For the seller

The sale of bare ownership can generate a taxable capital gain if it takes place within five years of the purchase of the property.
The capital gain is determined by subtracting the initial purchase cost, including any ancillary costs and documented costs for renovations or extraordinary maintenance, from the sale price.

No taxation is envisaged in the following cases:

  • when more than five years have passed since the date of purchase;
  • in the event that the property has been inherited, even if it is sold before the age of five.
  • if the home has been used as a main residence by the owner or his family members for most of the time it has been owned.

In the event of a taxable capital gain, at the time of the deed the seller can opt for the application of a substitute tax of 26%, which avoids ordinary IRPEF taxation.

For the buyer

Those who purchase bare ownership must pay:

  • the registration tax in the amount of 9%, or 2% if the requirements for the “first home” purchase are met;
  • mortgage and cadastral taxes, due in a fixed amount (50 euros each).

When will the buyer be able to use the property?

The buyer of the bare ownership will be able to fully use the property only at the end of the usufruct, i.e. when the usufructuary voluntarily renounces the right or in the event of death. Until then, the enjoyment and use of the property remain exclusively with the usufructuary, who can also rent it to third parties. It is important that the buyer is aware of this aspect: the actual availability of the property by the bare owner only materializes when the usufruct ends, from which moment the buyer can decide to live in the house, rent it or sell it as a full owner.

What happens if the owner dies before the usufructuary

In the event that the owner of the bare ownership dies before the usufructuary, the bare ownership passes to the heirs of the owner according to the testamentary dispositions or, in the absence of a will, according to the compulsory succession. However, the situation of the usufructuary remains unchanged: he retains the right of enjoyment of the property until the end of the usufruct, or until his death or other condition provided for in the contract. The heirs then become the new bare owners, but they cannot in any way limit the existing usufruct. When the usufruct ceases, the heirs acquire full ownership of the property.

Responsibilities and duties of the parties

In the bare ownership contract, the responsibilities and duties of the seller (usufructuary) and buyer (bare owner) are quite distinct. The usufructuary has the right to use and enjoy the property, but also the obligation to keep it in good condition and to provide for ordinary maintenance expenses, as well as utilities. It is also the usufructuary’s responsibility to pay taxes such as IMU, since he is the one who enjoys the property. He is also liable for any damage that may result from incorrect use of the property.

The bare owner, on the other hand, is required to bear extraordinary expenses (such as structural interventions or major renovation works), as well as all those expenses that are aimed at maintaining or increasing the value of the property in the long term. The general rule therefore provides that the usufructuary is entitled to all “ordinary” and current management expenses, while the bare owner is entitled to “extraordinary” expenses.

Both parties should work together for the proper management of the property during the usufruct period, thus reducing possible disputes and clarifying the division of expenses and tax obligations in the contract from the outset. A detailed conclusion of the contract helps to clarify responsibilities from the outset and protect the rights of both.

“Buying bare ownership can be advantageous: the purchase cost is lower than full ownership, allowing savings on initial taxes (e.g. registration tax).”

Bare ownership vs other real estate investments

Comparing bare ownership with traditional real estate investments, substantial differences emerge in terms of returns, risks and time horizons. Traditional investment in real estate offers immediate control, the possibility of rental income, but requires more capital and involves ongoing management responsibilities.

Bare ownership offers several benefits: a lower initial investment, the possibility of significant long-term gains and the absence of management burdens during the usufruct period. However, it involves risks due to the unpredictability of completion times and the absence of immediate gains.

This form of investment is particularly suitable for investors with long time horizons, limited capital availability, and moderate risk appetite. It is not suitable for those looking for immediate returns or need short-term liquidity.

Future Market Trends

The bare ownership market is registering growing interest, especially in Milan., fueled by various demographic and economic factors. The aging of the Italian population creates an increasingly large pool of potential sellers interested in this solution to monetize real estate assets.

The economic difficulties of many households make it attractive to access real estate investments with low outlays. At the same time, uncertainty in traditional financial markets is driving investors towards tangible assets such as real estate.

From a regulatory point of view, there is a greater focus on innovative forms of real estate investment. Possible future developments could include specific tax breaks or procedural simplifications to facilitate this type of transaction.

Demographic evolution and changes in living habits could significantly influence the bare ownership market in the coming years, creating new opportunities but also new challenges for operators and investors.

Conclusions

Bare ownership represents a complex real estate solution but full of opportunities, both for those who sell and for those who buy. A thorough understanding of its dynamics, advantages and responsibilities of the parties involved is essential to assess whether this choice is in line with one’s financial and personal needs. An informed decision, supported by in-depth knowledge, allows you to reap the benefits of this formula, avoiding unpleasant surprises and contributing to a more serene and conscious management of real estate investment.

Bare Ownership FAQ

What is bare ownership?

Bare ownership is a form of real estate sale in which the right of ownership is separated from the right of usufruct. The buyer of the bare ownership (bare owner) owns the property but cannot use it as long as the usufructuary – often the seller – retains the right of habitation or use of the building.

When can the buyer use the property?

The buyer acquires full right of use (full ownership) at the end of the usufruct, which generally occurs upon the death of the usufructuary or at the end of the term set in the contract. Only then can he live, sell or rent the property without restrictions.

What rights remain with the usufructuary?

The usufructuary has the right to live in the property and to receive any income (for example, from renting). He must use the property diligently and keep it in good condition, without changing its intended use. However, he cannot carry out extraordinary interventions without the consent of the bare owner.

Who pays taxes and property expenses?

The usufructuary is responsible for the payment of IMU, TASI and TARI (the latter as the occupant), according to art. 9, Legislative Decree no. 23/2011.

The expenses are divided as follows:

  • Ordinary maintenance and current management: to be paid by the usufructuary, as established by art. 1004 of the Italian Civil Code.
  • Extraordinary interventions and structural expenses: they are the responsibility of the bare owner. However, it is essential to specify that some condominium expenses must be divided according to the type of intervention carried out.

Does bare ownership have tax benefits?

Buying bare ownership can be advantageous: the purchase cost is lower than full ownership, allowing savings on initial taxes (e.g. registration tax).

As for capital gains in the event of future resale, taxation is not automatic but varies according to several elements, such as the use of the property as a main residence or the time elapsed since the purchase (if more than 5 years have passed, no capital gains taxes apply).

Is bare ownership a safe investment?

Bare ownership can be an excellent investment in the medium to long term, thanks to the reduced initial cost and potential revaluations of the property. However, there are risks related to uncertainty about the duration of the usufruct and the future trend of the real estate market.

What are the main risks?

The main risk is the unpredictability of the term of the usufruct, which can last many years. In addition, the bare owner has no legal possibility to expedite the acquisition of full ownership, as usufruct is a right protected by the Civil Code. Tax or market changes could negatively affect the profitability of the investment.

Are there any practical examples of using bare ownership?

Bare ownership is often chosen by seniors who want to obtain liquidity while maintaining the right to live in their own home. For example, a retired couple can sell bare ownership of their home, keeping the usufruct for life and receiving a sum of money immediately without having to move. It is also an attractive option for investors who want to buy real estate at a reduced price while waiting for full ownership.

What are the legal aspects to take into consideration?

Before buying or selling bare property, it is essential to consult a notary or real estate expert. The contract must clarify the rights, duties and conditions of the parties, including any clauses on succession or waiver of usufruct.

What happens in the event of the death of the usufructuary?

Upon the death of the usufructuary, the right of usufruct is automatically extinguished and the bare owner acquires full ownership of the property without further charges. The heirs of the usufructuary cannot claim any rights to the property, unless specifically agreed.

Is it possible to sell or donate bare ownership or usufruct?

Yes, both rights (usufruct and bare ownership) can be sold, donated or transferred to third parties, unless otherwise stipulated. These operations must still be formalized with a notarial deed.

The content of this article is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute professional advice and does not replace the advice of qualified experts. Before taking any action based on what you have read, you are advised to consult professionals competent for your specific situation. The author and the site do not assume responsibility for any errors, omissions or regulatory updates subsequent to publication.

DID YOU KNOW YOU CAN EARN € 800 A WEEK WITH SHORT-RENTALS?
Income Diversification
Overlay Image
DID YOU KNOW YOU CAN EARN € 800 A WEEK WITH SHORT-RENTALS?
Income Diversification