When you decide to renovate a property, the first concern is almost always about the budget. Between materials, construction companies and unforeseen events, the temptation to save on professionals is strong. One of the most frequently asked questions among homeowners in Italy is: “Can I renovate without hiring an architect?”, “When is it possible?”, “What are the pros and cons of renovating my house myself?”, “Can I do the renovation work myself?”.
The short answer is: yes, it is not always mandatory to contact an architect. However, the complete answer is more complex and involves legal, practical and safety aspects that are often underestimated. Italian law almost always requires the presence of a qualified technician for interventions that go beyond the simplest routine maintenance. This technician does not necessarily have to be an architect: he or she can be a surveyor or an engineer, depending on the type of work.
Choosing the correct figure is essential to avoid legal problems, inefficiencies or risks to the safety and value of the property.
In this article we will analyze the skills of the different professional figures, practical examples and legislative references, as well as the risks of underestimating a qualified construction management during a renovation of a property.
Renovating a house without an architect: pros and cons.
The key role of the architect in renovation
To decide whether to do without a professional, it is essential to fully understand what his or her duties are. Reducing the figure of the architect to the one who “draws the plan” or chooses the colors of the walls is a common but dangerous error of judgment.
The added value of a qualified technician lies in his ability to see the whole and manage critical issues.
Renovating a house without an architect is possible for routine maintenance ( painting, replacement of floors, fixtures, bathroom renovation without moving partitions). For works that modify the structure or the floor plan (CILA/SCIA), a qualified technician (often a surveyor, cheaper) is still required for building practices and safety.
Space design and optimization
The architect translates the client’s needs into functional spatial solutions. Often, an untrained eye cannot see the hidden potential of a property or, on the contrary, imagines technically unfeasible solutions. The professional draws up the preliminary, final and executive design, making sure that every centimetre is exploited to the fullest and that the ergonomics of the rooms comply with living standards.
Bureaucratic and administrative management
The Italian building regulatory landscape is notoriously complex and fragmented. The architect is responsible for drafting and submitting the necessary building practices (CILA, SCIA, Building Permit) to the competent municipal offices, also with the help of a team of professionals. In addition, he ensures that the project complies with the Municipal Building Regulations, health and hygiene regulations and energy saving laws. Without this competence, the risk of incurring building abuses, administrative sanctions or work stoppages is very high.
The Estimated Bills of Quantities
One of the most powerful tools in the hands of the architect is the bill of quantities. It is a detailed document that lists all the necessary works, quantified by size and unit price. This document is essential to request homogeneous estimates from construction companies. Without a bill of quantities drawn up by a technician, companies will provide estimates based on subjective evaluations, making it impossible to make a real comparison of costs and leaving the door open to continuous price increases during construction (the so-called “extras”).
Works and Safety Management
During the executive phase, the architect often takes on the role of Works Manager. In this capacity, he protects the client by checking that the company carries out the works “in a workmanlike manner”, respecting the project and the agreed materials. He also verifies the correctness of the site accounts, authorizing payments only against works actually carried out and verified.
Architect vs Interior Designer: What are the differences?
Although architects and interior designers often work closely together and share the goal of improving living spaces, their roles, educational backgrounds and legal responsibilities are profoundly different.
The architect is a graduate professional, registered in a professional register, who deals with design at 360 degrees. His expertise ranges from the structure of the building to the systems, up to urban planning. The architect has the legal and technical responsibility to modify the conformation of the building: he can knock down load-bearing walls, move windows, modify the façade and sign the building practices (such as CILA or SCIA) necessary to authorize the works in the Municipality. His work focuses on the building “box”, ensuring that it is safe, functional and in accordance with the law.
The interior designer (or interior architect, if he has a degree in architecture but specialises in interiors), on the other hand, focuses on the perception and use of the interior space. His intervention does not concern the load-bearing structure or urban planning bureaucratic practices, but the optimisation of existing environments. He is responsible for studying movement flows, lighting technology, the choice of finishing materials, the colour palette and the selection of furnishings.
While the architect builds or renovates the building, the interior designer “dresses” it and makes it habitable, working on the atmosphere, ergonomics and style to reflect the client’s personality. In summary, if you have to move a master wall, you need an architect; if you have to rethink the layout of furniture and the lighting of a living room, the interior designer is the key figure.

When is it possible to renovate without an architect?
Distinction between Ordinary and Extraordinary Maintenance when you renovate your home
To understand which renovation work can be carried out without the help of a professional, it is necessary to precisely classify the type of building intervention.
The Consolidated Building Act (Presidential Decree 380/2001) distinguishes between ordinary and extraordinary maintenance, restoration, conservative renovation, building renovation and new construction.
Ordinary Maintenance: Is “do-it-yourself” possible?
Ordinary maintenance includes interventions aimed at keeping the property in efficiency and decorum, without changing structural elements or main systems. These works serve to preserve the functionality and aesthetics of the home without the need for building practices or qualified technicians.
In these cases:
- It is not necessary to present any qualification to the Municipality.
- The intervention of a qualified technician is not required: you can directly commission the company or operate independently.
- It is mandatory to comply with safety and plant regulations: if you intervene on electricity, water or gas, the company must issue the Declaration of Conformity (DM 37/2008)
Important: some rules may vary between municipalities or in the presence of historical or landscape constraints. It is always advisable to inquire at the local technical office.
Practical examples of routine maintenance:
- Painting walls and ceilings
- Replace floors or walls without changing the structure
- Repair internal or external windows (handles, glass, hinges)
- Cleaning and routine maintenance of systems (without structural changes to the system)
- Replacement of taps or sanitary ware without moving the utilities
- Replacement of external fixtures and windows: To be classified as routine maintenance, the replacement of fixtures must maintain the same dimensions and must not alter load-bearing walls or the aesthetics of the building, respecting any local constraints on colors and materials.
- Minor repairs to floors, doors, roller shutters or fences
- Painting of wooden or metal railings, doors, windows or window frames
Extraordinary Maintenance: The obligation of the qualified technician
Extraordinary maintenance concerns interventions on deeper structural or functional elements. According to art. 3 paragraph 1 letter b) of Presidential Decree 380/2001, these are works necessary to renovate or replace structural parts of the building or integrate sanitation and technological services, provided that they do not alter the overall volume or intended use.
Practical examples of extraordinary maintenance:
- Moving or opening of internal partitions.
- Construction of a second bathroom.
- Complete renovation of the electrical, water or heating system.
- Replacement of the central boiler.
- Opening of new windows or interior doors (without changing the façade).
- Demolition and reconstruction of non-load-bearing partitions.
- Moving the kitchen to another room.
- Partial renovation of the roof (without volumetric increase).
- Changes to the centralized condominium systems.
- Interventions to improve accessibility (e.g. removal of architectural barriers).
For these works:
- It is mandatory to submit a building practice to the Municipality, usually a CILA (Sworn Notice of Commencement of Works) for extraordinary light maintenance interventions, such as moving non-load-bearing partitions or remaking systems.
- In the case of structural changes or significant changes, such as the opening of new windows on facades or changes to load-bearing walls, a SCIA (Certified Notification of Commencement of Activity) is required.
- The paperwork must be certified by a qualified technician (architect, engineer, surveyor).
Other Types of Works: Restoration, Renovation and New Construction
In addition to ordinary and extraordinary maintenance, there may be restoration and conservative renovation work (typical of historic buildings), building renovation (which leads to a different organization, including structural organization) and new construction.
In these cases, the figure of the qualified technician is always required, often even with more advanced levels of specialization, and it will be necessary to present more complex building practices (SCIA, Building Permit).
The Professional Figures in Renovation: Architect, Surveyor or Engineer?
As we have seen, the law requires the use of a “qualified technician” in most cases when you want to renovate your home.
But who are these professionals and how to choose them?
The choice between architect, surveyor and engineer depends on:
- Type and complexity of the job.
- Possible presence of constraints (historical, landscape, anti-seismic).
- Required design level (technical or even aesthetic/architectural).
The Surveyor: what he does in a renovation
The surveyor is a technical professional, specialized in civil construction, cadastral practices, management of construction site activities and construction management on interventions of limited magnitude.
In the renovation of the following are the responsibility of the surveyor:
- CILA and SCIA practices for extraordinary maintenance without complex structural changes
- Design and supervision of internal renovation works in houses and apartments
- Cadastral Registration and Changes (DOCFA)
- Bills of quantities and accounting of works
- Drafting of declarations of conformity and energy certifications
Surveyor’s limitations:
- It cannot design or direct work on multi-storey buildings with significant load-bearing structures.
- It cannot intervene independently on listed properties or in historic centers without specific authorizations.
- It cannot design or direct interventions involving load-bearing structures in seismic areas.
Practical examples of what a surveyor does in a renovation
- Surveyors can design and direct works that involve non-structural internal changes, such as moving partitions, as long as no work is done on load-bearing walls or structural elements.
- They can deal with internal renovation work, such as the renovation of bathrooms or kitchens, which do not involve structural changes.
- They can design and direct work on systems (plumbing, electrical, etc.), as long as they are not complex technological systems or require advanced calculations.
- This is a fundamental limitation for surveyors. They cannot intervene on structural elements such as load-bearing walls, floors or beams.
The Civil/Construction Engineer: Skills and Roles in Renovation
The civil or construction engineer is the indispensable professional for all interventions involving structural elements, building stability or innovative solutions in the seismic, energy and technological fields.
Engineer skills when renovating:
- Design and structural calculation for building and infrastructural works, even complex ones.
- Works supervision for modifications on load-bearing structures (e.g. opening on load-bearing walls, modification of floors, structural reinforcements).
- Seismic adjustments and static improvements in risk areas, with preparation of the related technical documentation (NTC 2018).
- Design and management of complex technological systems (e.g. thermal power plants, advanced photovoltaic systems, air conditioning systems).
- Preparation of technical reports related to structural safety and energy performance.
When the engineer is needed:
- Demolitions or openings on load-bearing walls.
- Structural reinforcements on buildings, especially in seismic areas.
- Design of advanced plants or complex infrastructures.
- Seismic or energy retrofitting interventions to improve the safety and efficiency of the building.
Practical example of what a civil engineer does in a renovation:
- If you need to open a gap in a load-bearing wall or reinforce a slab, the engineer is essential to ensure that the modifications comply with safety regulations.
- For seismic retrofits or energy requalification projects (thermal insulation, photovoltaic systems), the engineer draws up the necessary calculations and reports.
The Architect: Planning, Design and Constraints in a Renovation
The architect is the professional who, in a renovation, combines technical and artistic skills, focusing on the functional, aesthetic and regulatory design of built spaces.
It is the reference point for interventions that require creative solutions or operate on listed properties.
Architect’s skills:
- Architectural design, with particular attention to the aesthetics and distribution of internal and external spaces.
- Works management for interventions on listed buildings (historical, landscape) or subject to particular restrictions.
- Recovery of attics, extensions and new distributions of interior spaces.
- Enhancement of the property through design and furnishing projects.
- Consultancy for interventions on prestigious buildings or in historic centers, with coordination of the necessary paperwork at the Fine Arts or other protection bodies.
When you need the architect if you renovate:
- Renovation of listed buildings or in historic centers, where design sensitivity is required to respect the historical and landscape context.
- Design projects to improve the livability and aesthetics of a property.
- Extensions, elevations and recovery of existing volumes (e.g. attics).
- Interventions that aim to maximize functionality, brightness and living comfort.
Practical example:
- If you are renovating a house in a historic center subject to the constraints of the Fine Arts, the architect guides you in the design and management of the necessary authorizations.
- To redesign the interior spaces of an apartment, creating brighter and more functional environments, the architect offers innovative solutions that combine aesthetics and practicality.
Important:
The skills and limits of professionals may vary slightly depending on the municipality, region and type of intervention. Before starting any work, it is always recommended:
- Contact the municipal technical office
- Consult a licensed technician to evaluate permits, practices, and legal responsibilities
Renovating without an architect: our final tips
It is not mandatory to contact an architect for every type of renovation, but it is always mandatory to contact a qualified professional for any intervention that goes beyond the less complex interventions of simple ordinary maintenance.
In any case, relying on a qualified professional is always the best choice. A professional, thanks to his training and experience, guarantees accurate design, compliance with regulations, cost optimization and a final result that really enhances your property.

